Feb 16, 2015

AFL

The Continuing Curse of Norm Smith

11 Comments

I’m not a superstitious man. I don’t believe in Astrology, the Loch Ness Monster or that Terry Wallace really ever had a five-year plan.

I do however believe in the curse of Norm Smith. Why? Because I am a man of science (despite barely passing it at school) and the curse of Norm Smith has more supporting evidence than the passing fad that is evolution.

Norm Smith was as player and coach for Melbourne from 1937 to 1967 (with a few short detours). He invented modern coaching.

He played in four Premierships for Melbourne and coached the demons to six flags. That means he was involved in ten out of the twelve Premierships Melbourne has won.

This included a run where they made the Grand Final in 1954, lost to Footscray, won the Premiership in 1955, 1956 and 1957, were beaten by Collingwood in 1958, and then won flags again in 1959 and 1960.

Melbourne entered the 1960s as the powerhouse club of the league and the team of the Establishment (I swear this is all true. Really).

In 1964 Melbourne won its 12th flag. The future was bright.

Yet a storm was brewing. One that would curse the club till quite possibly the end of time (perhaps longer).

On a dark Friday night in 1965 a courier delivered a termination notice to Smith at his home. A courier! It was the 1960′s equivalent of being sacked by text.

The sacking was a result of long simmering tension between the committee and the coach which was further fuelled by Ron Barassi’s controversial move to Carlton that year.

There were suspicions Smith had supported this move to rid himself of a potential rival as coach. Something that was patently untrue. It instead had all the hallmarks of a committee who thought the coach had got too big for his boots.

Smith gave an emotional interview to Tony Charlton following the sacking. The interview shows how passionate Smith was about Melbourne. A passion that arguably wouldn’t be matched again. Here is a short feature of the fallout:

Smith was reinstated shortly after due to overwhelming media and supporter pressure but the damage was done. He was gone by 1967.

The manner of Smith’s sacking and the fact he was sacked at all has resulted in a curse that is real in the way reality TV is not. Who put the curse on? Its best if we don’t worry about facts too much, they tend to get in the way of curses.

It took 22 years, from the sacking, for the Demons to make the finals again in 1987. Not just the Grand Final, the finals at all. Twenty-two years! I almost managed to finish high school in that time.

Considering this was the club of the establishment, it is amazing how this was allowed to happen. Let’s be honest, despite the jokes, the ski fields in Victoria are not that good.

In 1988, when the Demons finally made it back to the Grand Final they were smashed by Hawthorn by 96 points.

Their 2000 Grand Final appearance was not much to write home about with the game over in the first quarter and the Bombers cruising to a 60 point win. The curse was still angry.

Throughout these events the curse of Norm Smith has reached out time and time again to bring misfortune on the club.

The curse was in full effect in the 1987 preliminary final when club legend Jim Stynes famously crossed the mark to allow Hawthorn to kick a goal after the siren to win.

Perhaps an even bigger impact of the curse was the impact on the career of Melbourne player David Schwarz.

It’s easy to forget how good a player David Schwarz was. In 1994 he led the competition in marks. He was on his way to being a superstar. The first Melbourne would have had in a very long time. Don’t believe me? Have a look at this:

The curse however ensured Schwarz would suffer not one, not two but three serious knee injuries. Injuries are part of the game but Schwarz was a once in a generation player for the Demons and his injuries took away the star power and the key forward Melbourne have lacked since the sixties.

Since then, the bad luck has continued. In recent years the curse manifest on Earth, in the form of the unholy trinity of Cameron Schwab, Chris Connolly and Mark Neeld.

Now we have poor Christian Petracca injure his anterior cruciate ligament at training. He'll miss out on all of 2015. This is devastating for him and for the fans.

The curse of Norm Smith is real and shows no sign of calming down.

The curse’s impact is mostly felt on the supporters. It ensures that what can go wrong, does go wrong at the worst possible moment.

But curses are made to be broken.

My favourite sporting curse of all time was the curse of the Bambino. In 1918 the Boston Red Sox, a championship club at the time, traded Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees.

Babe Ruth would go on to become the greatest player of all time. For the Red Sox, the curse resulted in an 86-year period of no World Series wins. In the same time the Yankees went on to win 27 championships.

Red Sox fans went to great lengths to break the curse including placing a Red Sox cap on top of Mt Everest.

In 2004 the curse was finally broken. How did they do it? By sensible drafting and recruiting of players, good management and some luck.

To me, despite my superstitious belief in the curse of Norm Smith, I’m afraid the same will be the only cure to the curse.

At the moment it seems while things such as good management and sensible drafting seem to be being addressed, one thing remains beyond Melbourne, just the tiniest sliver of good luck.

COMMENTS

curious

Feb 17, 2015

Nice story - except it misses a couple of bits that the biography "Red Fox" makes plain.

'64 flag was the last of an era starting with Checker Hughes as coach and Smith as player in the late 1930s. They knew they pinched it - a karma pay back for 58.

By 64 the other clubs had caught up and the side that won in 59/60 had not been topped up.

So although Melbourne started on top in 65 with a bunch of close wins, Smith was well aware things weren't right from the footballing side of things, and in particular the club needed to significantly recruit and rebuild.
However his relationship with the committee members became a major problem. It suffices to say that when he was sacked, Melbourne were still top 4 and he was the reigning premiership coach with 6 flags in 10 years, equalling Jock McHale. So not a performance thing.

While there is no doubt Melbourne were due a few poor years from 1965 on, the long period of underperformance is properly sheeted home to the club, as teams prepared to compete harder for recruiting and utilise rule changes saw results, and Melbourne did not keep pace with those sides.

So 'the curse' was not Smith's ghost (died suddenly in 1973 in his mid 50s) as such but was the attitudes of the off-field individuals that led to the sacking as well as an insufficient response to increased competition for recruiting from other clubs.

As for star recruits getting injured - yes poor luck but not exceptional - ask Geelong.

Tony Tea

Feb 19, 2015

Professionalism also came in right at the wrong time for Melbourne. We had overestimated our power in the comp, right at the same time as the so-called big clubs started to gear up. Also, zoning was brought in to stymie Melbourne and was meant to be a rotating thing, but as soon as the clubs with the better zones realised they did indeed have the better zone, they successfully lobbied to have the rules changed and they kept their strong zones.

PS: Our family had a reasonably close connection with one of the 1965 Melbourne committeemen, and he confirmed to me they thought Smith was indeed getting to big for his booties; a situation which was brought to a head when he refused to apologise for abusing an umpire early in 65.

The Glass Eye

Jun 18, 2018

Perhaps Smith should have taken the umpire out for a coffee instead (or 6 o clock swill), Alistair Clarkson style.

Jarrod

Jul 16, 2018

The curse continues in 2018 Titus - Jake Lever

Ron J

Oct 01, 2018

Committemen belong in the office, NOT on the footy field
Norm Smith (the greatest coach of all) belongs on the field and club rooms NOT in any committee room
Norm was paid to coach not listen to any wankers in a committee room

Wazza D

Aug 10, 2019

Sheedy warned Essendon about the curse that getting rid of a long-term coach, using Smith as his example (about 7 weeks before the Essendon board sacked him). Haven't won a final since. Maybe the footy gods think legends get to choose when they walk.

Mick

Aug 28, 2021

Norm Smith was too direct for the petunias on the committee. The poor little petals didn't understand when told to leave the coaching to the coach. He told the precious ones in the committee to eff off and look after finances and@cups of tea and cucumber sandwiches. That's all. That's why@Melbourne had a great winning coach and a shit committee.

Simmo

Aug 29, 2021

I can't believe I am even typing this.
Titus, we're only 2 wins away from burying the curse.
I can't work out who I want to win the Norm Smith medal though. Head says Oliver, heart says Max.

James Styles

Sep 11, 2021

Hi Titus,
There’s another Curse going on right now & it’s at Essendon when Kevin Sheedy and James Hird ended their Respective Coaching & Playing careers in 2007, that was the Start of the Infamous Curse that Continues to haunt the Bombers in the Finals to this day. Seven Different Coaches were tried since that time (even Current Melbourne Coach Simon Goodwin coached the Side for One Game in 2013 when the ASADA Supplement Scandal was going on) but none of them had Managed to get the Bombers into Week 2 of the AFL Finals, Most Recently losing to the Western Bulldogs (Who won the 2016 Flag from Seventh while an Inexperienced Essendon finished with the Wooden Spoon), But still they have a Huge Fan Base around Australia that Sheedy and Hird made into since the 90’s Baby Bombers era.

Patrick

Sep 13, 2021

Perhaps the curse was over the MCG and by having the final in Perth, it will be enough to lift the curse finally?

Robert Chapman

Sep 25, 2021

Hey Coleman's brother also died
How p!ssed off , do you think he was seeing his brother& Family treated as such no doubts all was loyal too the Demons on his Death Bed
Seeing his Brother Shatted.
If you ever wonder where a curse truely comes from its the source. Not the sacked coach
Furious energy directed at the club, look now Demons blowing a 21 point lead, trailing 1st half? By 8 points first half saying Karma

I just feel, there's a deep seated energy there
From the past🎯 still half a game left too prove me wrong, ? Yes never treat people bad
But if such a Curse existed no doubts it would come from a diving brother seeing his idol destroyed which at the time he was.
Just my spin on such a Curse if one existed 🎯🔱