Sep 08, 2025

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Finals Week One

19 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spreadsheet-dominated rational exercise.

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Adelaide (55) v Collingwood (79)

Adelaide sort of returned to finals for the first time since 2017, and it would be fair to say they were very rusty.

Probably the most glaring problem was the decision to kick the ball to Darcy Moore every time they went forward.

It confused me so much as a strategy that I googled, ‘Does Darcy Moore play for Adelaide?’ during the game.

Google informed me he doesn’t, but the Crows players didn’t seem to know this.

With the Crows butchering any move forward, the Pies responded with seven consecutive goals either side of half-time.

With not much happening for them on the field, some of the Crows fans took to booing Isaac Quaynor.

Quaynor’s crime of course was being on called a slur that would get you sacked in most workplaces.

In the AFL it gets you a trip to Italy.

It was disappointing, especially there are plenty of good reasons to boo Collingwood.

Add to that, the Crows would have lost this even with Rankine. They were poor all round.

Playing the victim as a club all week has not helped them.

The Crows are going need a complete mental reset if they’re going to make it past next week.

Friday

Geelong (112) v Brisbane (74)

It probably tells you all you need to know about this game, that Brisbane’s only real highlight was when the umpires gave them back-to-back goals from free kicks.

With Geelong well in control, Cam Rayner flopped in a display so dramatic it would have been seen as overly theatrical even on Broadway. 

Then, despite the umpires showing they were in a mood to hand out ridiculous frees, Zach Guthrie decided to shoulder Rayner from behind.

It was a silly decision, especially given Rayner seems to have the balance of a toddler.

Yet even these two goals couldn’t put the momentum in the Lions favour.

Brisbane looked tired, and soon, they were injured.

Lachie Neale is now out for the foreseeable future with a calf injury, Hugh McCluggage has a sore knee and Eric Hipwood, who didn’t play, is now out for the season.

Hipwood went in for a scan relating to a calf injury, only to discover a partial ACL tear.

It’s a bit like going to the mechanics to get an oil change and discovering you need a new motor.

The good news is we all get to see Geelong in a Preliminary Final!

Such a rare event, like seeing a unicorn.

Saturday

Greater Western Sydney (88) v Hawthorn (107)

If you love drama, this provided Real Housewives levels, as two of the more exciting teams in the competition put on a show.

The Giants came out strong early but couldn’t make it count before the Hawks got going.

When they did, they were brutally efficient, converting up forward to the tune of seven goals in the first quarter.

The procession continued in the second and third quarters, in which the Hawks got out to a 42-point lead midway through the third quarter.

I was watching at the Sorrento Hotel, which is on brand for a Melbourne supporter, and it was full of Hawthorn fans feeling very happy about being Hawthorn fans.

And yes, I know that’s their default state.

Then the Giants woke up and got moving. Here came a goal, then another, and now a third.

The mood in the front bar of the Sorrento Hotel got a bit real. I tried not to let my squeals of excitement get too loud.

Then came a fourth, fifth and sixth goal to the Giants.

There was a goal in it at three quarter time. ‘What a wonderful day,’ I thought.

The Hawks fans looked dazed and confused. It was really great.

But credit where credit is due, the Hawks steadied. Under pressure they didn’t lose their heads.

The Orange Tsunami turned out to be nothing worse than the waves gently crashing outside the window on the foreshore.

That Hawks were home safe.

In a nice gesture, a Hawks fan I’d never met bought me a drink.

“I was hoping you’d win,’ I said as we clinked glasses.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Fremantle (79) v Gold Coast (80)

Fremantle fans don’t ask for much, which is lucky because their team doesn’t give them much.

At home, against a club that’s never even played in a final, this should have been a win, but the Dockers don’t really do easy.

What they do is make things as painful as possible for their supporters.

Four goals in a row saw them six-points up with 3:21 to play.

The lead was theirs; the momentum was theirs.

“Oh no,” thought their fans.

So of course, Suns DEFENDER Mac Andrew then took a big mark and kicked a goal.

Then, David Swallow, the first player the Suns ever drafted, who I thought retired several years ago, marked, and kicked the deciding point.

It was just his fourth disposal of the game.

This was pure Fremantle, and their fans knew it.

Now the Suns face the injured Lions, in what I believe is the biggest final to ever be played between two Queensland teams.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

JP

Sep 08, 2025

“Now the Suns face the injured Lions, in what I believe is the biggest final to ever be played between two Queensland teams.”

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Excellent

PENGUIN

Sep 08, 2025

“I was hoping you’d win" Oh Titus. You have won the internet!
I have no-one to barrack for, except the horse with the party hat. Sigh

Rooboy

Sep 08, 2025

High Quality, as usual, but it feels like you're going soft on Hawthorn ...over one beer-bribe?! C'mon man! Just think of every, nay ANY, Hawthorn supporter you know before you write next week and you'll remember why you sling off at them the way you do/should. We trust you!
I don't think Quaalude was being booed for any alphabet-related issue, they were booing him (and Collingwood) for dobbing. The woke media in Radelaide and elsewhere have lost their minds about when one is now "allowed" to boo, but I'm pretty sure it dates back to ancient Rome, right? It's simple: Pay money to event organiser, get unlimited booing potential at your personal discretion.

Al

Sep 08, 2025

Someone left the anchor ⚓ out for Freo.

WA Bogan

Sep 08, 2025

There's a gravity centre not far north of Perth (https://gravitycentre.com.au/). The rumour is that they will sponsor the Dockers next year with the slogan: Just like gravity, the Dockers will always let you down ...

Son of plugger

Sep 08, 2025

Very harsh this Monday, Titus. But very fair.

Yep, the hawk fans looked dazed and confused, but not for long it’s so true.

And yes, Titus shows us yet again that the truth of sport plays rings around us.

Snag Cleaver

Sep 08, 2025

Surely David Swallow’s “mark” for the deciding point in the Duckers v. Suns game came from a free kick which he earned for a delightfully orchestrated incorrect disposal while being legitimately tackled.

The G Train

Sep 08, 2025

Agree with everything you wrote, Titus. Everything. Especially Rayner’s balance issue.

Should players be penalised by the umps for their opponent’s lack of balance? I lack balance in all things, and am treated very harshly and given no quarter.

Rayner lacks balance, yet is shown a whole lot of love. By the umps, at least. An ump, at least.
Rayner’s polite chat with the ump worked quite well. But—may have been just a coincidental communication breakdown??

Doug

Sep 08, 2025

The Rayner free was correct interpretation of the rules. They don't change for the finals. Rayner was pushed in the back, when he would least have expected it. If what Connor did was OK, then why aren't all players doing it all the time?

Andrew of 3040

Sep 08, 2025

Hey @Rooboy , it wasn't Quaynor who dobbed. But those booing didn't care and probably still don't.

Max

Sep 08, 2025

Living in Brisbane, i was just invited to the Brisbane Suns game on the weekend...

papaschmidt

Sep 08, 2025

No one has ever said "I was hoping you'd win" to a Hawthorn fan.
ever.
Ever.
EVER.

Bluesman

Sep 08, 2025

@PAPASCHMIDT, You are incorrect.
I always say to Hawthorn fans "I was hoping you'd win" if they're playing the Collingwood Filth.
But I don't really know many Hawks fans, so it's not really an issue.
Titus is one up though, a free beer.

Doug Piranha

Sep 08, 2025

That sounds like a very Sorrento kind of Saturday afternoon Titus. Plenty of my fellow Hawks supporters, in a bar and on good terms with themselves, along with the odd Dees supporter who may have voted to merge with the Hawks back in '96. I might have said the same to a Pies supporter if there was a free drink in it. Probably not to a Dons supporter though.

Sally Trevena

Sep 08, 2025

Always read and love your AFLM reviews. When do you plan to start reviewing the AFLW?

Rooboy

Sep 09, 2025

I know I'll get hacked for this, but VERY unemotionally @Sally Trevana - people will comment on AFLW when it reaches a worthy standard. Crowd numbers (1000 - 3000 at most games) and low TV viewing numbers suggest they are not there yet. It's a loss to the AFL of $50M p.a. BTW.

Ros Otzen

Sep 09, 2025

At 7.05 to go in the last quarter, there was Cam losing his balance again! He really should get help for this ongoing issue.

DON FRANCISCO'S SISTER

Sep 09, 2025

".......people will comment on AFLW when it reaches a worthy standard. Crowd numbers (1000 - 3000 at most games)......."

If the AFLW had more fights the crowds would increase for sure.

Straight Up The Guts

Sep 09, 2025

Wow wee (thanks Brian) just when you thought those invisible people on the ground in green fluorescent tops & tight green shorts couldn’t over influence, control or dictate the game any more - little Terry does a wonderful job of bringing world attention to a one sided game. His dad Big Terry must be wondering how Benny cocked this up so badly. I’m hoping Benny gets more finals - here’s definitely more entertaining than Snoop Dog & that Meatloaf chap.

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.