May 19, 2025

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Ten

40 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise. 

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Gold Coast (104) v Hawthorn (96)

What a classic.

This is the way to convert people on the Gold Coast to Australian Rules, by playing exciting games in Darwin.

The Suns got off to a fast start in this one and led by 32 points during the second quarter.

With Hawthorn looking done, they went to their old faithful, ducking in tackles for frees.

It’s a tactic that works for them, especially their small forwards. Jack Ginnivan, Nick Watson and Dylan Moore are all masters of the art.

It’s great to see that when the AFL attempts to do something to prevent head injuries, instead of supporting that, players use it to draw frees.

And I know it’s just not Hawthorn players, but it’s more fun to bag Hawthorn.

The Hawks got back into the game, with frees delivering them a 6.1 return, which is why they do it.

The Suns of the past would have thrown their hands up and stopped after giving up a lead, but they rallied and came back.

Gold Coast looks like a serious football team for the first time ever. Hawthorn and the umpires are both serious scalps.

Friday

Sydney (78) v Carlton (62)

For Carlton fans, it was a result as predictable as it was depressing.

Ahead for most of the game, the Blues just couldn’t put the Swans away.

Not to worry, they were still leading at three-quarter time, and the Swans have struggled to score this year. Actually, to worry.

The last quarter saw the Swans boot five-goals-to-two as once again the Blues forgot there are four quarters. I mean, it’s right there in the name.

Another problem the Blues couldn’t fix was Issac Heeney, who ran amok.

He finished with 38 disposals and 10 clearances, as well as two goals, as the Blues players forgot you’re allowed to tackle him.

One negative for the Swans was Joel Amartey’s incredibly stupid late head high shoulder bump on Jordan Boyd.

It was in the dying moments, and after only getting him back from injury, this was the last thing the Swans needed.

Saturday

Collingwood (78) v Adelaide (68)

Collingwood are going to win a Premiership. It’s inevitable.

They’ve now won eight of their past nine games and the run home is good.

They have thirteen games left, and eleven of those are in Melbourne.

Eight of those are at the MCG, while the other three are at Marvel, and two of those are Collingwood home games. The other is against North.

This is all worth remembering when Collingwood next complain about the ‘massive’ advantages interstate teams get.

Despite the ongoing rain, this was an entertaining game, with the Crows refusing to go away.

The difference was the Pies took their opportunities, and sometimes they made opportunities out of nothing.

Bobby Hill’s goal in the first quarter was an example, as he booted the ball out of the air, on an angle and through the goal at pace, almost landing in the third row.

It was an astounding display of athleticism.

Even I leapt off the couch when I watched it, which is an astounding display of athleticism for me.

Yes, I did pull a hamstring.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Port Adelaide (39) v Geelong (115)

All Port fans ever wanted was for Ken Hinkley to be shown the door. They thought the grass would be greener on the other side.

It’s a bit like when I dared Cathy Jenkins to break up with me if she was ‘so unhappy’.

Sometimes getting what you want can backfire. Please come back Cathy, I was a fool.

This was less a game and more a chance to injure players.

Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Bowes, Jason Horne-Francis and Lachie Jones all went off with hamstring injuries, followed by Josh Sinn going off with a hip injury.

That all happened before half time.

It turned out the Cats could cover their losses better than the Power could, with Jeremy Cameron kicking seven goals, as the Power seem to focus on not getting more injuries.

Greater Western Sydney (61) v Fremantle (95)

Like marriage, the key to football is not letting your opponent do what they want to do.

In this case, the Dockers didn’t let the Giants get their run off half back going at all.

It was a display of footballing IQ and execution that Freo have lacked for most of the season.

Are things coming together finally for the Dockers?

Shai Bolton seemed to be finding his place, connecting the forwards, and Luke Jackson was much happier as the number one ruckman.

Fremantle are now ninth, not bad for a team that’s been out of form all season.

Even more importantly, this was a win over the Giants, who sit in eighth.

They’ve lost four of their past five games but luckily have Carlton next week.

Western Bulldogs (127) v Essendon (36)

The Bulldogs are performing miracles this season, given their injuries, and the ease at which they brushed aside would have them feeling confident about their future.

The only caveat to that is Essendon applied about as much pressure as a feather landing on you.

Tackling, chasing, harassing, being within several metres of an opponent, these were all things the Essendon players had no interest in.

For a team that’s been rebuilding forever, this is not what you want.

Let’s put Essendon’s rebuild into perspective, it’s been going for about twenty years, depending on where you count it from.

Compared to other engineering feats, it’s a long build.

The Hoover Dam took five years, the Panama Canal took eight and the International Space Station was a twelve-year build.

The Egyptians took twenty years to build the Pyramids, but they had the help of aliens.

Worryingly for Bombers supporters, some builds take a very long time.

The Great Wall of China was continuously being built for 2,300 years.

For Bombers supporters, it feels like this rebuild has been going on that long.

Sunday

Richmond (74) v North Melbourne (78)

When you’ve only won 17 games in your past 117 games, and you haven’t won at the MCG since 2017, a victory is sweet.

Perhaps too sweet, as North fans those kids who have never been allowed sugar, they’re just not used to it.

Suddenly, this is like going to a kid’s birthday and getting all the red cordial and lollies you can consume.

North got lucky in many ways. Despite leading for most of the game, they seemed very keen to give their lead away late, making a series of mistakes but luckily for them the Tigers were just as mistake prone.

After last week’s draw against Brisbane, North fans have now gone a fortnight without losing, and it’s not even the offseason.

Brisbane (88) v Melbourne (99)

Never in doubt. That’s exactly what I thought as I watched the Dees get close, drop away, get close, and drop away and then finally go over the top.

The Lions seemed to have just enough to keep the Dees at bay, until suddenly they didn’t.

Melbourne put the pressure on all game, but as they have done so any times before, couldn’t make that count on the scoreboard.

But this time they didn’t relent, instead they went one further and played a fourth quarter in one of the great upsets of the season.

Max Gawn has been the heart and soul of the Dees for years now, but this recent recovery from a terrible start has been driven by him.

He was everywhere again, and with the game in the balance, he took several key marks to keep the ball in the Dees forward half.

The Lions will be wondering how they let a game they were in control of slip. It’s a simple answer but it was effort.

Like the T-1000, the Dees didn’t stop, they just kept coming. The Lions were a bit more like a robot vacuum that got stuck under a chair.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

West Coast (108) v St Kilda (80)

In the wake of the heartbreaking news of Adam Selwood’s death, it seems a bit silly to really discuss a football game.

But there was a sense that this first win of the season by the Eagles was an attempt by the club and its players to honour one of their own.

Of course, that is but a small thing in the scale of things but wanting to honour the memory of someone who meant a lot is the most human of things, and that’s all footy is, a community of people, all connected, all with a shared love and all reeling together at how difficult this life can be.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Bomber Bill

May 19, 2025

That's a heartfelt final summary Titus. Well said.

Doggie Dancer

May 19, 2025

VALE Adam Selwood

Michael Morse

May 19, 2025

VALE ADAM SELWOOD

AN EAGLE forever and forever in our hearts

Brilliant summary of the EAGLES game and glad to get the W

Rooboy

May 19, 2025

"Hawthorn and the umpires are both serious scalps." GOLD!! - So funny but sadly so true. The "Free kick Hawthorn" mantra is back! And Hawthorn fans, spare me the frees for/against stat's - as listed above by Titus - it's those shocking collapsing-knee head-high frees that are a blight on the game. The saving grace is that flog Sicily had two potential marks of the year taken on his head - SO good!

Bomber Bill

May 19, 2025

That's a heartfelt final summary Titus. Well said.

Adam

May 19, 2025

The Egyptians took twenty years to build the Pyramids, but they had the help of aliens.

Gold!

Kate

May 19, 2025

You're spot on about us North fans and winning. I think I need to thrash my six year old at Monopoly tonight so he doesn't get too used to this whole 'victory' feeling.

G-Rant

May 19, 2025

Thankyou for the respectful and appropriate coverage of the West Coast v St Kilda game Titus.
Vale Adam Selwood.

Jeremy Collett

May 19, 2025

please unsubscribe me thanks

Syd Swan

May 19, 2025

Another great summary of the round

I feel like you rehash the Carlton match report every week, just changing the opponents to keep it up to date.

Perfect summary of the WCE game.

Hui

May 19, 2025

Only jealous people use the word “Flog”

Zane Insane

May 19, 2025

I know other teams try it, but Hawthorn are masters of the undeserving free kick game.

Gyfox

May 19, 2025

Titus - please put the Essendon rebuild in perspective. The Suburban Rail Link will ta e 30 years. Essendon is just following the state government’s example.

Greg moss

May 19, 2025

As good as ever T.O., but what pray tell is a T1000 (asking for Simon Goodwin).

Peter Marr

May 19, 2025

All your comments are worth a read, but your genuine appreciation and thoughtful words on the Eagles V Saints game maybe your best yet, well said.

Scott Andrews

May 19, 2025

Beautifully crafted words at the end.

Don Francisco's Sister

May 19, 2025

Let's keep ESS's rebuild in perspective, shall we?

Construction on Cologne Cathedral in Germany began in 1248. It was halted on 1560, still unfinished.

If ESS can get through the next 300 years without crumbling into rubble I think we should consider that an indication of real progress.

Stephen

May 19, 2025

Actually, Titus, I think Essendon are using knock-off second-hand Lego bricks.

fitzroy forever

May 19, 2025

great summary as always Titus. deepest sympathy to the Selwood family.

Kafka’s Ghost

May 19, 2025

Regarding the Essendon build-time, La Sagrada Familia in Barcelona is still a work in progress. It’s only been about a century. The caveat though, is that it’s magnificent. Unlike the Bombers.

Ken Olah

May 19, 2025

Like Rooboy said

Fifth umpire

May 19, 2025

Spot on Titus, Pies are strictly a local Melbourne delicacy. The AFL could move some of their games to rural Victoria. I won't insult anybody's intelligence by explaining why that will never happen.

Son of plugger

May 19, 2025

Perhaps your finest KJR yet, Titus.

I was telling everyone I know (about 3 or 4 people)—that after The Ds truly magnificent victory,, Titus will be feeling unusually happy and content. And thus his Monday KJR will lack the usual stinging acerbic gut wrenching vindictive comedic heartbreaking poetical irrational idiotic hysterical nonsensical satire that we all appreciate.

I was wrong.

Kossy from Gladstone, qld

May 19, 2025

Superb summation on how my team played to avoid more injuries. Poort.

The g train

May 19, 2025

Nice one, Titus. Agree with everything you wrote.

I usually fact check everything Titus writes, and he’s usually spot on. But was very skeptical about the pyramids taking just 20 years to build, with the help of aliens. As usual, Titus was spot on.

On the other hand, Titus was comparing an Essendon “rebuild” with a Pyramid “build”—not quite the same. If the pyramids fell of a cliff, and if those same aliens withdrew their services, how long might a Pyramid rebuild take?

RIP Adam Selwood.

Fat Side

May 19, 2025

Maybe we stop calling them the Hawks and start calling them the Ducks.

Ryan

May 19, 2025

I'm with Kate, my lad needs some disappointment in his life this week with North winning
Indoctrinating my son into the North fold, I've given him 80 years of heartache, please NMFC, prove me wrong.

PR

May 19, 2025

“Like marriage…”
For someone who professes to be unlucky in love, you sure seems to have hit the nail flush on the head with this one!

Max

May 19, 2025

Written to me by a mate who's a mad blues fan "I've just realised why vossy, despite liking the bloke, is never going to be a premiership winning coach: he's done an MBA"

Woody

May 19, 2025

Now that West Coast have remember how to win a game, they'll be pumped to see who they've got next, their traditional pull-their-pants-down team of yore ... the team in the eight most unlikely to play finals ... drum roll ... Kuwarna

Robert Carmichael

May 19, 2025

Thank you for your words of condolences and contemplation on the vicissitudes of life in your Eagles v Saints report. I am glad you didn't mention anything about the poor form of the Saints. If l want to feel depressed l only have to listen to Ross Lyon's press conference where he mainly reports on stats and says uninspirational stuff like "We are not a team that just rolls out and wins"

Robbie C

May 19, 2025

Thank you for your words of condolences and contemplation on the vicissitudes of life in your Eagles v Saints report. I am glad you didn't mention anything about the poor form of the Saints. If l want to feel depressed l only have to listen to Ross Lyon's press conference where he mainly reports on stats and says uninspirational stuff like "We are not a team that just rolls out and wins"

sonofcatcus

May 19, 2025

Titus,

Greatly appreciate your words on Adam Selwood.

However on my hawkers, Ginnivan started his trade at the filth. The wizard & Dylan are now experts at lowering the knees.

For years, I watched as that other Selwood with the head bandage at Geelong recieve free after free after free...

Happens every rule change, this time the hawks have mastered it. Your jelousy shows amigo.

Hans Van de Graaff

May 19, 2025

Your final comment summed it all up. Beautifully said. Also, as a lifelong Carlton supporter I wish AFL was like ice hockey, with 3 periods. Just saying.

Nathan

May 19, 2025

Amongst the idiotic hysteria - thank you for the heartfelt summary of WC game. Vale Adam Selwood

Angela Quach

May 19, 2025

Thank you for capturing the sentiment about Adam Selwood so perfectly.

Richmond pommie

May 19, 2025

As a psychiatric nurse i appreciate your heartfelt comments on Adam Selwood
Lets hope we can support each other and reduce the stigma of mental illness

FatOldBaldBloke

May 19, 2025

Titus I am submitting this weeks game summary to the Nobel Literature committee. If you don’t win I would be very surprised.

Jeremy S

May 19, 2025

You so often make me laugh Titus, your final comments have made me well up. Beautiful words.

Biggus D

May 19, 2025

Reading the Knee Jerk is like watching Pretty Women - you laugh, get angry, get hopeful, and cry. Thank you for keeping my multiple personalities alive.

BTW Cathy says hi, and she wants her Big Freeze beanie back.

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.