Mar 30, 2026

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Three

22 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise. 

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Geelong (68) v Adelaide (60)

Don’t let the close score fool you. This was a tougher watch than a politician’s Instagram feed.

A combination of wind, hail, Adelaide injuries and whatever Geelong were doing, made this an error-filled affair.

Geelong didn’t look that convincing throughout this, while the Crows were workmanlike given the absence of many key players.

Of course, it all came down to a key moment when a kick was awarded to Tom Atkins after he and Zac Taylor went for a ball near the boundary.

Despite the ball going out off Atkins boot, the umpire awarded the kick to Geelong under the lasso rule.

Apparently, the ARC can review these things, but didn’t, because the system is overly complicated and weird.

The AFL has admitted the umpire’s error, and it’s obvious this was the key moment and the Crows would have certainly won if it had been called correctly.

Geelong should have the four points taken off them and be stripped of draft picks for the next ten years. 

This week’s Sports Bizarre Podcast takes us to the world Romario, Ronaldo and Ronaldinho

Friday

Collingwood (87) v Greater Western Sydney (54)

I know the ladder means less than a horoscope at this point of the season, given no one really knows what round it is, but the Giants sit a lowly 15th.

Against Collingwood, they looked less like an Orange Tsunami and more like a spilt can of Fanta.

With everyone concerned about Collingwood’s forward line woes, it was the Giants who looked about as dangerous as a plastic spork.

It’s not that hard to figure out what has gone wrong; eight key Giants are currently out injured. If I were the Giants, I would try to have fewer injuries.

Collingwood seemed to have no problems scoring. Even better, they seemed to have gotten their spark from the first gamer Oscar Steene.

Steene had to wait over 1100 days to make his debut.

It was a bit like a tag team match in the WWE, when one guy is getting belted forever, and finally, after the longest time, the other guy gets tagged in and tears the place apart.

In Steene, the Pies have found the solution to all their problems. No pressure on him at all. I can’t wait for the Copeland when he just beats out Nick Daicos. 

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Saturday

St Kilda (80) v Brisbane (113)

St Kilda’s return on investment from their offseason cash splash is a bit like mine when I invested in a relatively unknown North Korean cryptocurrency called Fraudcoin.

Looking back, fraud is not Korean for ‘Enormous riches’ as I’d been told. That one is on me.

St Kilda were foolish anyway to think you can buy success in the AFL.

The way to be successful is to set up as an expansion team in a location that is actively hostile to the sport.

We all know Ross Lyon has made it his life work to make his teams close to unwatchable, so when it took 20 minutes for the first goal to be scored, most neutrals would have switched off.

I didn’t because my family wanted to spend time with me, so I had to pretend this game was ‘really important’.

“This has huge ramifications for the top ten!”

Fremantle (103) v Richmond (43)

Richmond certainly didn’t embarrass themselves in the first half, especially given that they didn’t have any recognised ruckmen, or several other key components of a modern AFL side.

Unfortunately for the Tigers, AFL games have a second half.

That’s what separates the top teams from the bottom, being able to play a full four quarters.

Well, other things separate them, too, I guess. Like good players, skills, coaching, a gameplan, fitness, the fixture, training facilities, home field advantage, one of their fans goes and makes a cup of tea at the wrong time, culture, recruiting, salary cap management, list management, good administrators, AFL handouts, the blessings of the footy gods, blind luck, a limited amount of stuffing up.

But yeah, four quarters.

Fremantle are in their prime, but they always find a way to irritate their own fans.

This week it was their goal kicking, which is a classic for them.

Kicking 13.25 is fine against the Tigers but Dockers fans are very confident they’ll pull this nonsense in a key final.

Essendon (69) v North Melbourne (81)

Chernobyl, Exxon Valdez, the Hindenburg, the Charge of the Light Brigade and the Essendon Football Club. All man-made disasters that could have been avoided.

With sixteen losses in a row, the Bombers have imploded like a billionaire’s submarine.

This was a race to see who was worse, and North gave it a real crack, but even they couldn’t match the malaise that hangs around this Essendon side.

North can now finally say they are better than Essendon, but that’s a bit like saying you’re better than Tiger Woods at driving.

One point of interest was when Tristan Xerri smeared blood on the face of Andrew McGrath. 

This used to be how you got welcomed into most private boys' schools, but now, it’s significantly frowned upon.

What a nanny state. Once if you didn’t finish the game covered in an opponent’s blood, and ideal some of your own, you hadn’t played hard enough.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Sunday

Port Adelaide (90) v West Coast (92)

West Coast has won two games in a row!

What heady times these are to be an Eagles supporter.

Amazingly, this game kicked off at 12pm Adelaide time, which is 9.30am in Perth. Even worse, this game was at 9:30 pm in New York, and 3:30 am in Paris.  

I can’t believe the AFL aren’t considering the people of Paris when scheduling Port Adelaide games.

Port got out to a strong start, four goals to none, only for the Eagles to get back into the game.

Those first four goals though, were all kicked by players named Jack. The simple conclusion is Port needs to recruit more players named Jack.

Carlton (77) v Melbourne (100)

If I was Essendon, I’d send Carlton a fruit basket or similar to thank them for distracting the footy world.

There’s been some spectacular collapses in history. Lay Down Sally, Kevin Spacey’s career, the Bronze Age. Now we can add Carlton to that list.

The Comedy Festival has only just started but the Blues have already won Most Outstanding Show.

Up by 43 points, it’s hard to convey just how in control of this game Carlton were in the first half.

The Dees barely saw the ball in the first quarter and only got vaguely acquainted with it in the second.  

Blues fans went into half-time feeling good, but still very aware they barrack for Carlton.

What happened next was both surprising and incredibly predictable.

The Dees got moving and the Blues reacted like they always do when things aren’t completely going their way, they froze.

Players stopped tackling, running, and trying.

Dezi Feeman should have hidden in Carlton’s forward pocket in the second half; no one would have found him.

Melbourne believed, Carlton didn’t.

Kysaiah Pickett set the tone from the second quarter, and dragged his team along, aided by 250 gamer Max Gawn.

Things are exciting when you don’t play the first half at all and still win comfortably.

Demons fans celebrated like the Luxury Car Tax had been lifted.

Melbourne do have some strategic flaws to address though. Mainly, the stark reality that you can’t play Carlton every week.   

The Blues now have the enviable task of pretending Michael Voss isn’t being sacked in the near future.

Byes: Gold Coast, Western Bulldogs, Hawthorn, Sydney.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Andrew Wynne

Mar 30, 2026

On fire Titus........................whatever you were drinking or inhaling this morning definitely paid dividends.

The Dezi Freeman analogy, will be one for the annals of comedic gold ;)

Brad

Mar 30, 2026

“If I were the Giants, I would try to have fewer injuries.” Perhaps there is a role for you in coaching Titus. Your insights are insightfully insightful.

Tige

Mar 30, 2026

Dezi Freeman should have hid in Carlton's forward line... Gold!

the g train

Mar 30, 2026

Agree with everything you wrote Titus--especially "Crows would have certainly won if it had been called correctly". But thought the idea of stripping Geelong 10 years of draft picks was a bit over top. In my opinion.

I managed to speak to the AFL umpiring coach and asked him about the incorrect call that certainly cost Adelaide victory. "Yeah, well, we've had a pretty quiet season and hadn't really won a game yet--but the game against Adelaide had us really pumped. We have a great rivalry with them--and to now have beaten them at the death 5 times in the last 3 years is really satisfying. Hopefully, this gets the ball rolling for us and we can win a few more close ones this season. We're still a chance for the top 10....".

Rodgher the Lodger

Mar 30, 2026

As a Melbourne supporter I was thinking about going home at half time. But I was already at home.

WA Bogan

Mar 30, 2026

A round that confirmed the league is made up of could-be's and won't be's...

Can Ross "The Grinch who made football unwatchable" Lyon please be charged with bringing the game into disrepute?

State League footy was better than the crap served up in these games, although the Lions and Dockers did step up a gear to show that they're in the "could-be's".

I propose that the Carlton-Melbourne game be renamed The Chardonnay Cup from this round forward.

The G Station

Mar 30, 2026

A bit harsh on Rossy, Titus.

Ross Lyon actually promised when he came back as the Prodigal Son, that he would play a bold attacking and up-tempo brand of Football. He's delivered. He's taken the Saints to an average of 11 goals per game in his second term as opposed to just 10 goals in his first term. That's a huge 10% improvement. Who can boast that!!?

Son of Plugger

Mar 30, 2026

Good stuff, Titus.

Really enjoyed your analysis of WCEs vs PA. Some of the arvo footy games start around 6-7 am in Paris. Perfect timing--when the game ends, you still have the whole day ahead of you as a tourist to see the (overrated) sights.

And loved your enthusiasm for WCEs. At the minute that are dead set premiership favourites And Harley Reid is the GOAT in waiting. (currently Tony Tockett). Everyone thought Harley was crazy for staying with The Eagles, but he Knew. He Knew. He somehow knew that a coach that nobody had ever heard off will take The Eagles all the way from 50 floors below the basement to the very summit of the footy world. And how did he know? He just KNEW....As The TAO teaches us "knowing without travelling, seeing without looking'.

Gary Ablett Jnr Jnr

Mar 30, 2026

‘Against Collingwood, they looked less like an Orange Tsunami and more like a spilt can of Fanta.

With everyone concerned about Collingwood’s forward line woes, it was the Giants who looked about as dangerous as a plastic spork.’

Chef’s kiss

A Dee in the West!

Mar 30, 2026

One of your best for some time! So many crackers in here but did especially like this reference: "Demons fans celebrated like the Luxury Car Tax had been lifted."!!!!

UpTheGuts

Mar 30, 2026

I love it when the umpires "get involved". Tommy Atkins stooged them a treat to a point where even the ARC wasn't considered. It got better when learned commentators got involved and stated prophesizing how that exact moment cost the Crows 4 points. What a bus trip back to Sadelaide that must have been. My prophesizing is that footy karma will square this up somewhere during the year when least expected and with maximum damage.
And the last leg of my quaddy here is - Round 7 - Ross to Carlton, Vossy to St.Kilda, Scotty (the one with not so good coaching record) to Manangatang (Ressies) and Scotty (the one with the good coaching record) to Hawaii - back in time about early September.

Jack

Mar 30, 2026

Is this week pi round, as in 3.14......?

Malcolm Turner

Mar 30, 2026

WA Bogan. We have moved on with Chardonnay to Sav Blanc to complement the charcuterie board at half time. Much cheaper than buying drinks & nibbles in the MCC. A great day to follow the Dee's yesterday.

KP

Mar 30, 2026

You're in a league of your own this week Titus, actually it's amazing how much funnier you are when Melbourne win, or lose, sorry I can't remember which one it is. Pure Gold this week.

Bailey Bayley

Mar 30, 2026

@UPTHEGUTS
I'd like to see Essendon and Geelong arrange a secret swap of coaches around that time and then sit back and wait to see how long it takes for the pundits to notice the difference.

Vic Parkes

Mar 30, 2026

Is ‘stooged’ another word for ‘cheated’? Funny how the only person who escaped Scott-free (get it? Scott … never mind) is Tom Atkins. A blatant cheat has borne no blame from anyone for being a cheat. I guess that says a lot about the commentary teams and the general footy media.

royboy

Mar 30, 2026

the season has officially started, you have played a blinder Titus, north Korean fraudcoin.

Woody

Mar 30, 2026

Clearly the Victorian State cricket team watched the Carlton second half a bit too closely ... instead of thinking "we'd better not do that", they went and thought "we can do better than that" and lost the Shield final in less than an hour, even quicker than Carlton getting pantsed in the second half

Jim Tilbrook's Cheque

Mar 30, 2026

Titus - once more, your football column demonstrates its unique place in the pantheon of sports commentary. I doubt that any other commentator raised the possibility that Carlton's collapse was possibly the most dramatic since the Bronze Age Collapse, circa 12th Century BCE. It is encouraging to reflect on the fact that the Bronze Age collapse lasted about 350 years, which most non Carlton supporters would consider to be barely enough to atone for the John Elliot era. Has there ever been a better time to be a Kozzie/Maxy loving, EV driving, cheeseboard loving, MFC supporter?

Mikea

Mar 30, 2026

Hearing your voice in my head as I read your musings is a bit like having Dennis back.
I did say a bit. I just wish you were still on telly. None of the replacement sports spot people have been anywhere near as dry, nor as witty.
Make a comeback…just not like Anthony Mundine.

Ped Ant

Mar 30, 2026

That was a tough read. No typos or grammatical errors this week. What is wrong with you? This should give hope to Carlton and Essendon fans.

Tiges Tragic

Mar 30, 2026

Your Blues/Dees report is literary gold. As ever, Titus :-)

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.